.webp)
Manhattan's Most Trusted Luxury Broker
Four decades of discreet, expert guidance for New York's most discerning buyers and sellers.
Why Caryl
A rare combination of deep expertise, trusted relationships, and unmatched market knowledge.
40 Years of Expertise
Four decades navigating Manhattan's most complex transactions for architects, artists, scientists, and collectors at the highest level.
Certified Senior Advisor
CSA designation ensures specialized knowledge for estate sales, downsizing, and life transitions — handled with care and discretion.
Realm & Compass Network
Access to Compass's global platform and the exclusive Realm network connecting ultra-high-net-worth buyers with extraordinary properties.
Notable Sales
A curated selection of distinguished properties represented by Caryl.
Sold
10 Park Avenue, PH25A
Murray Hill, Manhattan
 (1).webp)
Sold
11 Fifth Avenue, Apt 11R
Greenwich Village, Manhattan
Sold
$13.75M
1 Montague Terrace
Brooklyn Heights
Client Testimonials
Trusted by New York's most discerning buyers and sellers.
In the Press
Caryl's work and listings featured in leading publications.
The New York Times
Five Homes with Conversation Pits
March 2026
A feature highlighting unique architectural elements in luxury homes, including a property represented by Caryl Berenato that exemplifies the enduring appeal of thoughtful design.
Brownstoner
Brooklyn's Most Popular Listings
May 2022
1 Montague Terrace in Brooklyn Heights, listed at $13.75M by Caryl Berenato, captured attention as one of Brooklyn's most sought-after properties on the market.
Frequently Asked Questions
Answers to what buyers and sellers most often ask about working with Caryl.
Who is Caryl Berenato?
Caryl Berenato is a licensed luxury real estate broker at Compass in New York City with 40 years of experience representing buyers and sellers across Manhattan and Brooklyn. She specializes in co-ops, condos, townhouses, and estate sales.
What areas does Caryl Berenato serve?
Caryl serves Manhattan neighborhoods including Tribeca, West Village, Greenwich Village, SoHo, NoHo, East Village, Lower East Side, Flatiron, Chelsea, Hudson Yards, Upper West Side, Upper East Side, and Carnegie Hill, plus Brooklyn neighborhoods including Brooklyn Heights, Williamsburg, Carroll Gardens, Cobble Hill, Park Slope, Fort Greene, and Greenpoint.
What property types does Caryl Berenato specialize in?
Caryl specializes in Manhattan and Brooklyn co-ops, condominiums, townhouses, and estate sales — with particular depth in pre-war co-ops, full-floor and penthouse condominiums, and historic townhouses.
How long has Caryl Berenato been a real estate broker?
Caryl Berenato has been licensed as a real estate broker in New York for 40 years, with her entire career focused on Manhattan and Brooklyn residential property.
How do I contact Caryl Berenato?
Caryl can be reached by phone at (917) 804-7367 or by email at caryl.berenato@compass.com. Her office is at 110 Fifth Avenue, 3rd Floor, New York, NY 10011, or you can use the contact form on her website at carylberenato.com.